Compare brokers

Closed Sell High Risk Practice trade, no real money

Gold (XAU/USD) Sell at market

Scalping 5M setup EMA 9/21 scalper Data rules Published Ended 6 Nov, 07:51 UTC

−0.97R−7.3 dollars · Stop loss hit

Gold (XAU/USD) chart

Bid prices from the tracking feed. Press play to watch the trade.
Loading chartChart data is unavailable right now

Levels

Entry
4,043.44 zone 4,042.94 to 4,043.94
Stop loss
4,050.92 7.5 dollars from entry
Target 1
4,035.96 not reached
Target 2
4,028.48 not reached
Target 3
4,021.01 not reached
Filled
4,043.66 6 Nov, 07:36 UTC
Closed
4,050.92 6 Nov, 07:51 UTC

One third of the trade closes at each target, and the stop moves to the entry after target 1.

Why this trade

This is a mechanical short trade on Gold (XAU/USD) triggered by an EMA 9/21 scalper strategy. The 5-minute rule fires when the 9-period EMA crosses below the 21-period EMA while the price is below the 200-period EMA, which occurred at 4046.41 and 4046.60 respectively. XAU/USD is trading around 4043, down 1.11% on the day, with the daily trend pointing down. The strategy has a tested negative return of -0.02R per trade on gold. The stop loss is at 4050.92, placed safely above the daily S1 resistance level at 4048.77, with an initial target of 4035.96.

ChartPrice structure on the chart: trend, levels, volatility.

About the strategy: EMA 9/21 scalper

The most common scalping setup: on 5-minute bars, buy at market when the 9 EMA crosses above the 21 EMA while price is above the 200 EMA, and sell on the mirror image. London and New York hours only (07:00 to 20:00 UTC, weekdays), at most six a day per instrument. Stop 1.5 ATR (5-minute), targets 1R, 2R and 3R; the rest closes when the EMAs cross back, or after two hours.

Caveat: One year only (the price feed keeps a year of 5-minute bars): -0.03R per trade over 1,814 trades, gold -0.02R, Nasdaq 100 -0.04R. On EUR/USD, GBP/USD, USD/JPY and Bitcoin the same rule lost 0.17 to 0.20R a trade, because a 5-minute stop is only a few spreads wide, so it is not run there; that choice was made on the same data.

The idea, explained: Forex scalping

Timeline

  1. Entry filled 4,043.66
  2. Signal published 4,043.40
  3. Reason added
  4. Confidence scored Score 46
  5. Trade closed 4,050.92 Stop loss hit, −0.97R
  6. Loss review added
  7. Risk tag added High Risk, as of its publish time

Why it lost, against why it was taken AI review

The short trade expected XAUUSD to continue its intraday downtrend following a 5-minute bearish EMA crossover. Instead, price reversed almost immediately and surged to the stop loss.

The reason it was taken

This is a mechanical short trade on Gold (XAU/USD) triggered by an EMA 9/21 scalper strategy. The 5-minute rule fires when the 9-period EMA crosses below the 21-period EMA while the price is below the 200-period EMA, which occurred at 4046.41 and 4046.60 respectively. XAU/USD is trading around 4043, down 1.11% on the day, with the daily trend pointing down. The strategy has a tested negative return of -0.02R per trade on gold. The stop loss is at 4050.92, placed safely above the daily S1 resistance level at 4048.77, with an initial target of 4035.96.

What happened

Filled short at 4043.66 at 07:36 UTC, price managed a brief favorable excursion to 4041.78 (0.205R) during the entry bar. It quickly reversed course, climbing steadily over the next three 5-minute bars. This rally breached the daily S1 resistance level at 4048.77 and triggered the stop loss at 4050.92 during the 07:50 UTC bar, closing the trade at 07:51 UTC.

The entry reason did not hold

The strategy relied on short-term bearish momentum and holding below the daily S1 resistance. By the close, the price had surged above S1 and the fast EMAs, entirely negating the momentum that triggered the entry.

Lesson: No clear lesson: the setup was valid and the stop was hit by normal volatility.

Proof it was not edited

When this signal was published, its fixed fields were written to a record and fingerprinted with SHA-256. The fingerprint also contains the one before it, so a change anywhere breaks the chain. You can check it in your browser.

Hash
594ecd14a1823648729614f9ecdb936d1afea7ceca3792f0b349984aa68bb53e
Previous hash
e2bc3bd9b4a5aece845da48ed4f245ba2453e2ff4c2f1301243f9f2a9e94bf57
Show the signed record
{"v":1,"symbol":"XAUUSD","side":"sell","order_type":"market","timeframe":"5m","strategy":"scalp_ema_5m","source":"data","oco_group":null,"entry":"4043.44","zone_lo":"4042.94","zone_hi":"4043.94","sl":"4050.92","tp1":"4035.96","tp2":"4028.48","tp3":"4021.01","created_at":"2026-11-06T07:36:01Z","expires_at":"2026-11-06T07:51:01Z","max_close_at":"2026-11-06T09:36:01Z","prev_hash":"e2bc3bd9b4a5aece845da48ed4f245ba2453e2ff4c2f1301243f9f2a9e94bf57"}

Risk High Risk

  • Track record: flagged

    Its rule was not profitable after costs in every period we tested.

  • Type of trading: flagged

    Scalping trade: moves are quick, and the spread takes a bigger share of a small stop.

  • News: passed

    No high-impact release was due while the order waits or in its first 4 hours.

  • Costs: passed

    The spread is a small share of the stop distance (under 10%).

High Risk means at least one check flagged this trade. Size it smaller, or skip it if you only follow Cautious signals. This signal was published before risk tags existed; its tag was added afterwards, from the facts at its publish time.

Confidence

The mechanical strategy has a negative tested expectancy, though the stop loss is logically placed above daily resistance.

Signals scored 40-49 have won 49% of 47 closed.

Confidence is a score from 0 to 100 given by an AI model. It is checked against how signals in the same band really ended, so treat the measured rate as the evidence, not the score. Reading a track record

More on Gold (XAU/USD)

Copied!